Redline v2 — decide what you capture first

The popover now starts with the capture decision (what, and where), then the pages, then the two verbs. Settings has one visible door: the gear in the popover header. Filler lines are gone; a status line appears only when something happened. Updates install themselves.

1Menu-bar popover340 pt · controlSize small · capture decision → pages → verbs
1a · Idle, empty session · light
◫Sat 31 Oct 13:05
  • Header has exactly two icons: details (opens the window on Lane) and Settings. No “…” menu.
  • The capture box is the first decision on screen; Choose Area… is always one click away.
  • No footer. Nothing is printed unless it is news.
1b · Pages present + one return · dark
◫ 3Sat 31 Oct 13:05
  • The Capture button wears the scope icon, so what ⌥⇧2 will grab is never ambiguous.
  • Choosing a non-area scope keeps the saved area (“area kept”) — switching back to Area restores it.
1c · New Session… — the capture decision at the moment of starting · light
◫ 3Sat 31 Oct 13:06
  • New Session… never starts silently: it shows scope, area and inherited details in place of the pages, with Start Session as the default button (Return).
  • Choose Area… here dismisses the popover, runs the picker, and comes back to this step with the new size.
1d · Capture-scope menu from the keyboard (⌥⇧1) · dark
◫Sat 31 Oct 13:06
  • ⌥⇧1 opens this menu where the pointer is; one keystroke captures with that scope and makes it the session’s scope.
  • Browser Page grabs the front browser window’s page area (Safari, Chrome, Arc, Edge); the tab strip and toolbar are cropped.
1e · Update installed in the background · light
◫Sat 31 Oct 13:07
DEV03 · v1.4.2 (41)
a1b2c3d4 · Ben Hippler
Redline 0.6.0 is ready — restarts after you sendRestart Now
Capture ⌥⇧2Send 2 pages
  • One line, only while it matters. It never interrupts a session with unsent pages.
  • Cropped to the relevant part for this mock.
2Redline window · headerscope and area are part of the session, shown where the verbs are
2a · Current session · light
DEV03 Current
3 pages · not sent
Area · 800 × 600 Choose Area… Capture New Session… Send 3 pages
Today
DEV03 13:05
3 pages · not sent
OMS test lane 11:48
2 pages marked
1
2
3
  • No gear here: Settings is ⌘, (and the popover gear) — one surface, one door.
  • Cropped to the header and a slice of the content for this mock.
2b · Same, dark, Browser scope
DEV03 Current
3 pages · not sent
Browser Page Capture New Session… Send 3 pages
  • With a non-area scope, Choose Area… disappears from the header; it lives in the scope menu as “Choose New Area…”.
3Settings460 pt · one window, reached only from the popover gear or ⌘,
3a · light
Redline Settings
Capture
CaptureSaved Area
Saved area800 × 600 on Display 1Choose…
Capture shortcut⌥⇧2
Capture menu shortcut⌥⇧1
Ask what to capture on New Session
Sending
Send withAirDropOneDrive
Save PDFs to~/DesktopChoose…
Watch for returns in~/DownloadsChoose…
Sessions
Delete sessions older thanNever
20 sessions on this MacClean Up Now…
Deleting removes Redline’s own screenshots only. PDFs you sent stay where they are.
Updates
Install updates automatically
Version 0.5.0 · checked 13:02Check Now
Updates download in the background and install the next time Redline has no unsent pages. Your area, shortcuts and sessions are kept.
Redline 0.5.0Quit Redline
3b · dark · update ready
Redline Settings
Updates
Install updates automatically
0.6.0 downloaded · installs after your next sendRestart Now
Turned off: Redline still checks every 6 hours and shows “Update to 0.6.0” here and in the popover, but waits for you.
Capture
CaptureFront Window
Saved area800 × 600 on Display 1Choose…
  • Quit lives here (and ⌘Q in the popover): the popover has no menu left to hide it in.
  • 3b is cropped to the changed groups.
4Labels, keys, states

Strings

PlaceExact label
Popover header iconsEdit review details (tooltip + VoiceOver), Settings (tooltip “Settings (⌘,)”)
Scope segmented control (VoiceOver “Capture”)Area · Window · Browser · Screen
Target lineArea: 800 × 600 on Display 1 + Choose Area… · Window: Front window when you press ⌥⇧2 · Browser: Front browser page when you press ⌥⇧2 · Screen: Display 1 · 2560 × 1440; non-area scopes add area kept: 800 × 600
Empty pagesNo pages yet / ⌥⇧2 captures the area|window|page|screen
VerbsCapture ⌥⇧2, Send (empty, disabled) / Send 3 pages, OneDrive: Save 3 pages; New Session…, Open Redline
New-session stepTitle New session; subtitle The current 3 pages are kept as a past session.; groups Capture, Review details + Edit…; buttons Cancel, Start Session
Scope menu (⌥⇧1)Header Capture; Saved Area (1), Front Window (2), Browser Page (3), Whole Screen (4), Choose New Area… (A)
Status line (only when news)Captured page 4 · Sent · 3 pages · Saved to OneDrive · 3 pages · OMS test lane came back · 2 pages marked + Open · No front window to capture · No browser window in front · Redline 0.6.0 is ready — restarts after you send + Restart Now
SettingsGroups Capture, Sending, Sessions, Updates; rows as in 3a; captions as in 3a/3b; footer Quit Redline

Keyboard

Global: ⌥⇧2 capture with the session’s scope · ⌥⇧1 open the capture menu (1–4 or A picks and captures). Popover Tab order: Edit review details → Settings → scope segments (←/→ move) → Choose Area… → Capture → Send → New Session… → Open Redline. Return = Send when enabled, otherwise Capture; Escape closes. ⌘, opens Settings; ⌘N = New Session…; ⌘Q quits. New-session step: Tab scope → Choose Area… → Edit… → Cancel → Start Session; Return = Start Session, Escape = Cancel. Window: ⌘N New Session…, ⌘S Send, ⌘, Settings, ⌘F search.

Scope states

The scope belongs to the session and is copied to the next one. Area uses the saved rectangle; if none is saved, Capture first runs the picker. Window grabs the frontmost window of the app that was front before Redline (never Redline itself); none → status “No front window to capture”, nothing added. Browser grabs the frontmost Safari / Chrome / Arc / Edge / Firefox window, page area only; no browser in front → “No browser window in front”. Screen grabs the display the pointer is on. Choosing Window, Browser or Screen never clears the saved area: it is shown as “area kept” and comes back when Area is chosen. Choose Area… / Choose New Area… always replaces the saved area and switches the scope to Area.

Information architecture

The capture decision lives in the popover, above the pages, as a four-way segmented control with the target line under it — and again, unmissably, in the New Session… step, which replaces the page strip until Start Session. The window header mirrors the scope as a pop-up next to the verbs. Settings has one door: the gear in the popover header (⌘, from anywhere in Redline); the window has no gear and the popover has no “…” menu. Popover hierarchy, top to bottom: what is being reviewed (lane, build, commit, reviewer) → what will be captured (scope, target) → what has been captured (pages) → news (one status line, only when there is any) → verbs (Capture, Send) → session control (New Session…, Open Redline). Updates move into Settings › Updates and surface in the popover only when an installed update is waiting.

Still the biggest thing wrong

The popover still carries two jobs at once — deciding what to capture and reviewing what was captured — and the real fix is to make the session, not the popover, the unit of decision: every capture rule (scope, area, lane, build, commit) should be set once, when the session starts, and then stay out of the way. Today the new-session step is the only place that treats it that way; until scope and details are locked per session (with change visibly recorded on the PDF when they change mid-session), a reviewer can still produce a PDF whose pages were captured under different rules without anyone noticing.